Tuesday 30 July 2019

cv - Is it a good or bad idea to list declined fellowships (for a PhD program) on one's curriculum vitae?


E.g. as shown in the example here.




  • 2011—Centennial Fellowship, Princeton University Department of Atmospheric and Oceanic Sciences (accepted)

  • 2011—Top Student Award, University of Washington (declined)

  • 2011—Program in Climate Change Fellowship, University of Washington (declined)

  • 2011—Faculty Fellowship, Columbia University (declined)

  • 2011—Charney Prize, Massachusetts Institute of Technology (declined)

  • 2011—Regents Fellowship, Scripps Institution of Oceanography (declined)


  • 2011—Chair’s Award, Stanford University Department of Earth and Environmental System Science (declined)




Answer



Aeismail makes an important point about location: what's standard in Germany differs from what's standard in the US.


In a US context, I would strongly recommend against listing things like declined graduate fellowships. It will look strange, and even beyond that it can work to your disadvantage: everybody will already assume you declined several attractive offers, so giving an explicit list will do nothing but focus attention on what isn't on the list. (If the list of declined offers is short, readers will be disappointed, and if it's long, they'll spend more time speculating about what's missing than being impressed.)


The only time I'd recommend highlighting this sort of information is if for some reason you had to turn down a vastly more prestigious offer than the one you accepted. For example, maybe you were offered a tenure-track job at a top department, but ended up working as an adjunct in the middle of nowhere so you could take care of a relative. You should then make sure everybody knows this the next time you are able to apply for jobs. However, you should be very careful when doing this, because if the prestige difference isn't absolutely universally acknowledged, then you run the risk of offending people who feel you are unfairly denigrating a perfectly fine career path.


No comments:

Post a Comment

evolution - Are there any multicellular forms of life which exist without consuming other forms of life in some manner?

The title is the question. If additional specificity is needed I will add clarification here. Are there any multicellular forms of life whic...