Sunday, 28 May 2017

citations - Recreating images from a source


In the field I work in, it is customary to use a graphical representation of some mathematical concepts. For my thesis, I have been creating a batch of figures containing these representations. These figures are very similar to those in one of my sources. I am wondering if I should cite that source in some way.


Some of my considerations:



  • The general form of the images is widely used in the field

  • I am making all figures myself, so no direct copying



Answer



According to SIAM:




Note: Figures or tables created by someone other than the author or borrowed from a previously published source, even those created by the author him- or herself, must carry an appropriate credit line at the end of the caption. (See section 5.2.5 for additional information.)



Elsevier and IEEE have similar statements, which explicitly include the recreation of the figures.


If you have a source in mind already, it is probably safest just to cite it in the caption. However, if the form of the figure is indisputably widespread, then there is no need to cite it. I would generally follow the same fair use guidelines as does Wikipedia in such cases.


Examples I would not cite (because they are indisputably widespread):



  • Using circles and lines connecting them to represent a graph, G

  • A Hasse Diagram to represent all possible bit combinations

  • The format of a UML diagram (although I would refer to it as such)

  • A figure where I cannot identify an appropriate source with a reasonable amount of effort



Examples I would cite:



  • Any figures that I created for a previous paper ("adapted from [2]")

  • A figure from another paper that demonstrates a specific point, where demonstrating that same point is the reason for recreating the figure

  • A figure reporting data when I have not added to/modified the underlying data

  • Any time that I have a source in mind and I am unclear under which category it falls


No comments:

Post a Comment

evolution - Are there any multicellular forms of life which exist without consuming other forms of life in some manner?

The title is the question. If additional specificity is needed I will add clarification here. Are there any multicellular forms of life whic...