Friday 21 June 2019

bacteriology - How quickly is antibiotic resistance lost?


I would imagine the bacterial genome is highly conserved and limited in its space, but maybe I am wrong.


If you were to take a strain of antibiotic resistant bacteria and kept them isolated, but fed well and so forth, how long would it take for them to lose their resistance? A year? A decade? 100 years? 1000 years? At some point it seems like that trait would disappear, but I have no feeling for how long. Please support your answer with a relevant citation.


EDIT:



My purpose is simple: I am thinking about a strategy for dealing with antibiotic resistance. If we were to ban them across the entire world (could be impossible) how long would we need to wait before they would be usable again. If it was a matter of years, then we could almost do a rotation of existing antibiotics (if we had enough) because I would rather not live in post-antiobitic world.



Answer



Antibiotic resistances in bacteria is commonly encoded by extrachromosomal DNA, the plasmids. These are circular pieces of DNA, which are much smaller than the hosts genome and which replicate independently from it. See the image from the Wikipedia:


enter image description here


These plasmids can be transfered between different bacterial cells, which then also get resistant. Plasmids are divided between daughter cells, when the parent cell divides. One of the few exceptions seems to be Mycobacterium tuberculosis, which does not seem to carry plasmids but also develops resistances. It has been hypothesized that they contain extrachromosomal single-stranded DNA ("Does Mycobacterium tuberculosis have plasmids?")


Regarding your question: Plasmids which carry antibiotic resistances will only disappear, when the antibiotic is not seen for a while, since the cells, which don't carry it, have a growth advantage over cells who are still carriers (since they save the energy of forming the plasmid). However, these resistance plasmids are nothing new, evolutionary speaking. They appeared as a countermeasure against fungal toxins.


In the lab, bacterial strains loose plasmids within a few days, when not kept under selection pressure according to my experience. There are a few paper who looked into it:



No comments:

Post a Comment

evolution - Are there any multicellular forms of life which exist without consuming other forms of life in some manner?

The title is the question. If additional specificity is needed I will add clarification here. Are there any multicellular forms of life whic...