Wednesday 26 July 2017

genetics - Did the eugenics program in Nazi Germany have a measurable effect?



Did the killing or sterilisation of people considered as living a "life unworthy of life" in Nazi Germany have any measurable effect on the "average health" of Germany? Is there any statistical evidence that the rate of (a specific) mental or physical illness is lower in Germany compared to other countries that were not affected by the Nazis (I guess you would need to have data on the rate of that illness from before the eugenics program as well)?


P.S. Please note, I'm neither interested in discussing the ethics of eugenics, nor in condoning what has happened in its name under the Nazis. I just want to know what the result on average health (if there is such a thing) was.



Answer



As most of the comment have pointed it out, It's nearly impossible to find out. This is my try:


Dr. L Alexander wrote in his paper, Medical Science under Dictatorship:



Hitler issued the first direct order for euthanasia in Germany on September 1, 1939, as his Panzers moved on the Blitzkrieg of Poland. Organizations with humanitarian-sounding names were immediately set up to execute "health" programs, again, under deceptively, euphemistic terms. For example, questionnaires collected by a "Realm's Work Committee of Institutions for Cure and Care" gathered and reported information on patients who had been ill five years or more and who were unable to work. "On the basis of name, race, marital status, nationality, next of kin, whether regularly visited and by whom, who bore financial responsibility, and so forth," decisions were made at key universities about which patients should be killed by psychiatrists who had themselves never seen the patients.Likewise, the "Realm's Committee for Scientific Approach to Severe Illness Due to Heredity and Constitution" was exclusively devoted to the killing of children with congenital anomalies or chronic illnesses. In all, 275,000 people were put to death in these killing centers before the Nazi Holocaust.




enter image description here


Law for the Prevention of Offspring with Hereditary Diseases (July 14, 1933)



Anyone suffering from a hereditary disease can be sterilized by a surgical operation if, according to the experience of medical science, there is a high probability that his offspring will suffer from serious physical or mental defects of a hereditary nature. Anyone suffering from any of the following diseases is considered hereditarily diseased under this law:


1. Congenital mental deficiency,


2. Schizophrenia,


3. Manic-depression,


4. Hereditary epilepsy,


5. Hereditary St. Vitus’ Dance (Huntington’s Chorea),


6. Hereditary blindness,



7. Hereditary deafness,


8. Serious hereditary physical deformity.


Furthermore, anyone suffering from chronic alcoholism can be sterilized.



If anyone is trying to get the statistical evidence that Eugenics have even remotely successful, have look at this table:


enter image description here


Current Top 50 death causes of Germany. (Rate = $\frac{death}{1000}$)




They have started various ways to brainwash people, one of them was movies.


$\text{Ich klage an}$




(source: filmportal.de)


Plot: A woman suffering from multiple sclerosis pleads with doctors to kill her


Current Scenario: Germany Rank $18^{th}$ in the world in death due to Multiple sclerosis


Source:



  1. Alexander L. Medical science under dictatorship. N Engl J Med 1949;July 14.

  2. http://www.life.org.nz/euthanasia/abouteuthanasia/history-euthanasia6

  3. Table: WHO, World Bank, UNESCO, CIA and individual country databases for global health and causes of death.



No comments:

Post a Comment

evolution - Are there any multicellular forms of life which exist without consuming other forms of life in some manner?

The title is the question. If additional specificity is needed I will add clarification here. Are there any multicellular forms of life whic...